Monday, November 3, 2014

Chaim (Dalfin) Chronicles Carlebach Conundrum



This week marks the 20th Yahrtzeit of R' Shlomo Carlebach.

One of my first posts was to mark the 15th Yahrtzeit, and I noted that one needs to fill up with spiritual gas, at least once a year, perhaps by attending a Carlebach-style Kabbolos Shabbos.

One of the fascinating similarities I find between the Lubavitcher Rebbe and R' Shlomo, is that although they enjoyed a tremendous following during their lifetimes, they both have increased their popularity posthumously. Also, they both passed away 20 years ago, and they both have been subjects of several new biographies.



One of the jewels of Chaim's new book is the answer to Bray's question on my initial post on whom accompanies Shlomo in the following picture:



According to page 217 of the book, this photograph was taken in 1959 at the Kings Hotel in Yerushalayim.
Left to right: Yaakov Lerner, Shlomo, Chaim Adler, Yaakov Tzuker and Yosef Miletzky.

Photo courtesy of Yaakov Lerner.

UPDATE from Rabbi Dr Nathan Ophir, author of Rabbi Shlomo Carlebach: Life, Mission, and Legacy -

The photo is actually from August 1960 and not 1959. It was in 1959 that Adler who was a student in the Hevron Yeshiva, then located in Geulah, who first met Reb Shlomo and he organized this get together in the Kings Hotel the next summer.

3 comments:

  1. Please note that Rabbi Chaim Dalfin copied the description of this photo from page 207 of the biography by Rabbi Dr. Natan Ophir, Rabbi Shlomo Carlebach: Life, Mission, and Legacy. Unfortunately, R,. Dalfin did not give credit to his source. It was Dr. Ophir who contacted Lerner and Adler and found the identification here. The photo is actually from August 1960 and not 1959. It was in 1959 that Adler who was a student in the Hevron Yeshiva, then located in Geulah, who first met Reb Shlomo and he organized this get together in the Kings Hotel the next summer.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dr. Ophir, I am honored by your comment. Thanks so much for the information. I will update the post accordingly.

      Delete
  2. P.S. I enjoyed your book immensely!

    ReplyDelete